ADVERTISEMENT
  • News
  • New York
  • Technology
  • Culture
  • Entertainment
  • Sport
  • More
    • Politics
    • Lifestyle
    • TV
    • Games
Tuesday, June 24, 2025
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
FINCHANNEL
  • Home
  • Business
    • BANKS
      • GeoBanks
    • Finance
    • Insurance
    • Markets
    • Pharmacy
    • Press Releases
    • RealEstate
    • RealEstate
    • Finance
    • Insurance
    • Banks
      • GeoBanks
    • Markets
    • Press Releases
    • Personal Finance
  • World
    • Americas
    • Europe
    • Georgia
      • Media
    • Ukraine
    • Europe
    • Georgia
      • Media
    • Ukraine
    • Americas
    • UK local news
  • Travel
    • Hotels in Georgia
    • Tours in Georgia
  • Videos
    • Promos
    • Soundslides
    • TheClinics
    • TheHoteliers
    • TheUniversities
    • TheHoteliers
    • TheClinics
    • TheUniversities
    • BestWorkplaces
    • Soundslides
    • Promos
    • Banking Forum
      • Promos
      • Soundslides
      • TheClinics
      • TheHoteliers
      • TheUniversities
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
      • Analysis
      • GORBI
      • OP-ED
      • VISA Editorial
    • Analysis
    • Gorbi
    • Book reviews
  • Tech
  • Interview
  • People
    • lifestyle
    • Health & Beauty
      • Coronavirus
    • LifeStyle
    • Employment
      • MyCareer
    • Education
    • Media
    • Celebrities
  • Oil&Auto
    • Auto
    • Energy
  • EN
    • EN
    • GE
  • Home
  • Business
    • BANKS
      • GeoBanks
    • Finance
    • Insurance
    • Markets
    • Pharmacy
    • Press Releases
    • RealEstate
    • RealEstate
    • Finance
    • Insurance
    • Banks
      • GeoBanks
    • Markets
    • Press Releases
    • Personal Finance
  • World
    • Americas
    • Europe
    • Georgia
      • Media
    • Ukraine
    • Europe
    • Georgia
      • Media
    • Ukraine
    • Americas
    • UK local news
  • Travel
    • Hotels in Georgia
    • Tours in Georgia
  • Videos
    • Promos
    • Soundslides
    • TheClinics
    • TheHoteliers
    • TheUniversities
    • TheHoteliers
    • TheClinics
    • TheUniversities
    • BestWorkplaces
    • Soundslides
    • Promos
    • Banking Forum
      • Promos
      • Soundslides
      • TheClinics
      • TheHoteliers
      • TheUniversities
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
      • Analysis
      • GORBI
      • OP-ED
      • VISA Editorial
    • Analysis
    • Gorbi
    • Book reviews
  • Tech
  • Interview
  • People
    • lifestyle
    • Health & Beauty
      • Coronavirus
    • LifeStyle
    • Employment
      • MyCareer
    • Education
    • Media
    • Celebrities
  • Oil&Auto
    • Auto
    • Energy
  • EN
    • EN
    • GE
No Result
View All Result
FINCHANNEL
No Result
View All Result
Home Health&Beauty

Depressed people are just more realistic, right? Not so, says UC Berkeley study

The FINANCIAL News by The FINANCIAL News
October 22, 2022
in Health&Beauty
Reading Time: 4 mins read
19
A A
0
Data Shows That For Some Patients, DBS May Address Chronic Depression
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Are depressed people simply more realistic in judging how much they control their lives, while others view the world through rose-colored lenses, living under the illusion that they have more control than they do?

That’s the general idea behind “depressive realism,” a theory that has held sway in science and popular culture for more than four decades.

The problem is, it’s just not true, new research finds.

RelatedPosts

Jewish General Hospital, Montreal is the first hospitals in the world to fully implement EIAS across all surgical disciplines

Fullscript vs. Rupa Health: What the Acquisition Means for Providers and Patients

Signs Your Mental Health Is in Trouble and How to Fix It

Packaged bread can be considered ultra-processed foods

“It’s an idea that exerts enough appeal that lots of people seem to believe it, but the evidence just isn’t there to sustain it,” says professor Don Moore, the Lorraine Tyson Mitchell Chair in Leadership and Communication at UC Berkeley’s Haas School of Business and co-author of the study, in press at the journal Collabra:Psychology. “The good news is you don’t have to be depressed to understand how much control you have.”

Depressive realism

The concept of depressive realism stems from a 1979 study of college students examining whether they could predict how much control they had over whether a light turned green when they pushed a button. The original research concluded that the depressed students were better at identifying when they had no control over the lights, while those who weren’t depressed tended to overestimate their level of control.

Moore and his colleagues set out to try to replicate those findings as part of a broader effort to restore trust in scientific research, much of which is woven into the fabric of the scientific community and wider culture. Researchers are revisiting bedrock studies to shore up the most basic of scientific principles: Can the research—and its conclusions—be replicated?

Why test the theory of depressive realism in particular? Its decades-long infusion into science, culture, and even potential mental health treatment policy makes it important, Moore says. The original study, for instance, was cited more than 2,000 times in subsequent studies or research, according to Google Scholar.

“At the top of the list of reasons why we ought to revisit this particular article is its widespread acceptance in both the scholarly and popular literature,” says Moore, who studies overconfidence, confidence, and decision-making. “That means a lot of people are building theories or policies premised on this effect being true. If it’s not, it’s really important to establish that.”

Replicating the original study

Moore co-authored the study with University of California, Berkeley, psychology professor Sheri Johnson and former undergraduate student researcher Karin Garrett, B.A. ’21, along with University of Miami doctoral student Amelia Dev, B.A. ’17.

The authors studied two groups of participants, whom they screened for depression via a questionnaire. The first group of 248 participants came from Amazon’s Mechanical Turk, an online service that provides paid survey-takers and study participants from a range of backgrounds, in this case all over 18 years old. The second group was made up of 134 college students who participated in return for college credit.

See also  Jewish General Hospital, Montreal is the first hospitals in the world to fully implement EIAS across all surgical disciplines

The researchers added or used more modern and robust measurements for the study. For example, they added a mechanism to measure bias, and experimentally varied the amount of control participants actually had.

Participants performed a task similar to that in the 1979 study. In 40 rounds, each chose whether to press a button, after which a lightbulb or a black box appeared. Each was told to figure out whether pushing (or not pushing) the button impacted whether the light came on. After the rounds, each reported how much control they had over the light.

Both the online groups and college student groups were split into three experimental conditions. Each condition experienced different relationships between the button and the light during the 40 rounds. The participants in the first two conditions had no actual control over the light’s appearance, yet saw it illuminate one-quarter or three-quarters of the time, respectively. Participants in the third condition had some control, seeing the light three-quarters of the time after pushing the button.

The researchers were unable to replicate the original study’s results. In fact, people in the online group with a higher level of depression overestimated their control — a direct contradiction to the original study. That finding may be driven by anxiety rather than depression, the researchers note, an observation Moore says merits further study.

In the college student group, depression levels had little impact on their view of their control, the authors found.

Researchers also tested for overconfidence. Study participants were asked to estimate their scores on an intelligence test. Depression had no impact there, either.

Results undermine the theory

The results, Moore says, undermined his belief in depressive realism.

“The study does not suggest that there are benefits to being depressed, so no one should seek depression as a cure to their cognitive biases,” Moore says.

Imagine, for example, a manager hiring someone who is depressed because they believe — based on the original study—that the person is less likely to be overconfident and will have better judgment. That would be a mistake, Moore says.

While depression may not improve judgment, the issue of how to accurately gauge our level of control in various situations has broader implications throughout life, Moore says.

“We live with a great deal of uncertainty about how much control we have — over our careers, our health, our body weight, our friendships, or our happiness,” says Moore. “What actions can we take that really matter? If we want to make good choices in life, it’s very helpful to know what we control and what we don’t.”

Rachel Layne, UC Berkeley Haas

 

Tags: depressedPeople

Related Posts

Jewish General Hospital, Montreal is the first hospitals in the world to fully implement EIAS across all surgical disciplines
Health&Beauty

Jewish General Hospital, Montreal is the first hospitals in the world to fully implement EIAS across all surgical disciplines

by The FINANCIAL
June 24, 2025
0

Building on the successful use of ERAS in four surgical specialties, Encare’s long-term partner Jewish General Hospital (JGH) has committed...

Read more
Fullscript vs. Rupa Health: What the Acquisition Means for Providers and Patients

Fullscript vs. Rupa Health: What the Acquisition Means for Providers and Patients

June 11, 2025
Signs Your Mental Health Is in Trouble and How to Fix It

Signs Your Mental Health Is in Trouble and How to Fix It

May 28, 2025
Packaged bread can be considered ultra-processed foods

Packaged bread can be considered ultra-processed foods

April 29, 2025

Discussion about this post

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Teaching porn literacy

A sizable percentage of internet porn users, roughly 40% are women

January 17, 2024
EasyJet to fly to London from Stockholm Arlanda

The London Diplomatic List, Addresses, Contacts & Working Hours

January 23, 2023
Ampersand wins £22m five-year contract at London Zoo

Ampersand wins £22m five-year contract at London Zoo

June 25, 2012
Matthew H. Fleeger Drives Strategic Growth at Gulf Coast Western Through Technology Integration

Matthew H. Fleeger Drives Strategic Growth at Gulf Coast Western Through Technology Integration

June 19, 2025
Teaching porn literacy

Teaching porn literacy

January 17, 2024
Charged With Retail Theft? What to Know Before Court

Charged With Retail Theft? What to Know Before Court

June 24, 2025
Jewish General Hospital, Montreal is the first hospitals in the world to fully implement EIAS across all surgical disciplines

Jewish General Hospital, Montreal is the first hospitals in the world to fully implement EIAS across all surgical disciplines

June 24, 2025
Survey: Majority of CFOs prioritizing ESG investment

The CFO’s Five Hidden Cyber-Cost Centers (and How to Shrink Them)

June 24, 2025
President of Ukraine. Stop Russia

Ukrainian President to make first visit to Council of Europe in Strasbourg amid escalating war in Ukraine

June 23, 2025
Energy Management in Facilities: Tools for Calculating Efficiency

Energy Management in Facilities: Tools for Calculating Efficiency

June 23, 2025
ADVERTISEMENT

Popular Last 24h

  • Teaching porn literacy

    A sizable percentage of internet porn users, roughly 40% are women

    332 shares
    Share 133 Tweet 83
  • Ampersand wins £22m five-year contract at London Zoo

    3723 shares
    Share 1489 Tweet 931
  • Osman Gunes Cizmeci on Apple’s Liquid Glass: Beautiful, But at What Cost?

    25 shares
    Share 10 Tweet 6
  • Levi Pettit Launches Dornick Wealth Management With a Personalized Approach to Client Relationships

    21 shares
    Share 8 Tweet 5
  • Leon Botstein’s Five-Decade Transformation at Bard College

    357 shares
    Share 143 Tweet 89
  • Teaching porn literacy

    163 shares
    Share 65 Tweet 41
  • Ukrainian President to make first visit to Council of Europe in Strasbourg amid escalating war in Ukraine

    19 shares
    Share 8 Tweet 5

LATEST POSTS

Charged With Retail Theft? What to Know Before Court

Charged With Retail Theft? What to Know Before Court

June 24, 2025
Jewish General Hospital, Montreal is the first hospitals in the world to fully implement EIAS across all surgical disciplines

Jewish General Hospital, Montreal is the first hospitals in the world to fully implement EIAS across all surgical disciplines

June 24, 2025
Survey: Majority of CFOs prioritizing ESG investment

The CFO’s Five Hidden Cyber-Cost Centers (and How to Shrink Them)

June 24, 2025
President of Ukraine. Stop Russia

Ukrainian President to make first visit to Council of Europe in Strasbourg amid escalating war in Ukraine

June 23, 2025
Energy Management in Facilities: Tools for Calculating Efficiency

Energy Management in Facilities: Tools for Calculating Efficiency

June 23, 2025
Levi Pettit Launches Dornick Wealth Management With a Personalized Approach to Client Relationships

Levi Pettit Launches Dornick Wealth Management With a Personalized Approach to Client Relationships

June 23, 2025
Osman Gunes Cizmeci on Apple’s Liquid Glass: Beautiful, But at What Cost?

Osman Gunes Cizmeci on Apple’s Liquid Glass: Beautiful, But at What Cost?

June 23, 2025
In the U.S. and abroad, more young adults are living with their parents

Why More Adults Are Reconsidering Old Habits in 2025

June 23, 2025
CityBlue Hotels opens its first Beach Property in Kenya

CityBlue Hotels opens its first Beach Property in Kenya

June 19, 2025
65% of Europeans see EU membership as a good thing, the highest result since 2007 

The Enchantment of Ukrainian Women and Building Bridges through Luludate

June 19, 2025

LATESTBUSINESS

Valor Hospitality Partners announces two significant deals in West Africa,

Valor Hospitality Partners announces two significant deals in West Africa,

by The FINANCIAL
June 19, 2025
0

Markets will drop quickly if US enters Israel-Iran conflict: deVere CEO

Markets will drop quickly if US enters Israel-Iran conflict: deVere CEO

by The FINANCIAL
June 19, 2025
0

Matthew H. Fleeger Drives Strategic Growth at Gulf Coast Western Through Technology Integration

Matthew H. Fleeger Drives Strategic Growth at Gulf Coast Western Through Technology Integration

by The FINANCIAL
June 19, 2025
0

Iconiq 777 Hosts Pathways to Apprenticeship Awards Ceremony in Newark

Iconiq 777 Hosts Pathways to Apprenticeship Awards Ceremony in Newark

by The FINANCIAL
June 17, 2025
0

Tips for Remodeling on a Budget

Tips for Remodeling on a Budget

by The FINANCIAL
June 17, 2025
0

 ‘Why Did My Car Insurance Go Up for No Reason?’

Insurers boost private assets allocations as capital increases

by The FINANCIAL
June 17, 2025
0

Elite Lauches in Lebanon

U.S. Counts 1,873 Listed Billion-Dollar Companies, More Than the Next Eight Economies Combined

by The FINANCIAL
June 17, 2025
0

7 Digital Marketing Techniques for Business Owners in 2020

Lockton Surprasses $4 Billion in FY2025 revenue

by The FINANCIAL
June 16, 2025
0

GET IN TOUCH

Submit guest post/Letters to the Editor:

editor (at) finchannel.com

Sales & Marketing: (+995 558) 03 03 03 Email: marketing (at) finchannel.com

Whatsup: (+995 599) 96 52 52

Georgia:

(+995 599) 96 52 52 Email: editor (@) finchannel.com

Postal address: 17 Mtskheta str. Tbilisi, Georgia 0179 The FINANCIAL

RESOURCE

  • Work at the FINANCIAL
  • ePaper
  • Advertise in The FINANCIAL
  • Access ePaper
  • Guest posts
  • Contributed articles
  • AmericanStockNews
  • Coupon Codes
  • GLOSSY MAG
American Culture Center
ACC Partner

GUIDEBOOK

  • Meet our team
  • Invest in Georgia
  • Become contributor
  • Archive

FOLLOW US

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Youtube
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Business
    • BANKS
      • GeoBanks
    • Finance
    • Insurance
    • Markets
    • Pharmacy
    • Press Releases
    • RealEstate
    • RealEstate
    • Finance
    • Insurance
    • Banks
      • GeoBanks
    • Markets
    • Press Releases
    • Personal Finance
  • World
    • Americas
    • Europe
    • Georgia
      • Media
    • Ukraine
    • Europe
    • Georgia
      • Media
    • Ukraine
    • Americas
    • UK local news
  • Travel
    • Hotels in Georgia
    • Tours in Georgia
  • Videos
    • Promos
    • Soundslides
    • TheClinics
    • TheHoteliers
    • TheUniversities
    • TheHoteliers
    • TheClinics
    • TheUniversities
    • BestWorkplaces
    • Soundslides
    • Promos
    • Banking Forum
      • Promos
      • Soundslides
      • TheClinics
      • TheHoteliers
      • TheUniversities
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
      • Analysis
      • GORBI
      • OP-ED
      • VISA Editorial
    • Analysis
    • Gorbi
    • Book reviews
  • Tech
  • Interview
  • People
    • lifestyle
    • Health & Beauty
      • Coronavirus
    • LifeStyle
    • Employment
      • MyCareer
    • Education
    • Media
    • Celebrities
  • Oil&Auto
    • Auto
    • Energy
  • EN
    • EN
    • GE

© 2025 Intelligence Group llc

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.