ADVERTISEMENT
  • News
  • Technology
  • Culture
  • Entertainment
  • Sport
  • Travel
  • Music
  • More
    • Politics
    • Lifestyle
    • TV
    • Games
Tuesday, May 30, 2023
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
FINCHANNEL
  • Home
  • Business
    • BANKS
      • GeoBanks
    • Finance
    • Insurance
    • Markets
    • Pharmacy
    • Press Releases
    • RealEstate
    • RealEstate
    • Finance
    • Insurance
    • Banks
      • GeoBanks
    • Markets
    • Press Releases
    • Personal Finance
  • World
    • America
    • Europe
    • Georgia
      • Media
    • Ukraine
    • Europe
    • Georgia
      • Media
    • Ukraine
    • Americas
    • UK local news
  • Travel
    • Hotels in Georgia
    • Tours in Georgia
  • Videos
    • Promos
    • Soundslides
    • TheClinics
    • TheHoteliers
    • TheUniversities
    • TheHoteliers
    • TheClinics
    • TheUniversities
    • BestWorkplaces
    • Soundslides
    • Promos
    • Banking Forum
      • Promos
      • Soundslides
      • TheClinics
      • TheHoteliers
      • TheUniversities
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
      • Analysis
      • GORBI
      • OP-ED
      • VISA Editorial
    • Analysis
    • Gorbi
    • Book reviews
  • Tech
  • Interview
  • People
    • CityLife
    • Health & Beauty
      • Coronavirus
    • LifeStyle
    • Employment
      • MyCareer
    • Education
    • Media
    • Celebrities
  • Oil&Auto
    • Auto
    • Energy
  • EN
    • EN
    • GE
  • Home
  • Business
    • BANKS
      • GeoBanks
    • Finance
    • Insurance
    • Markets
    • Pharmacy
    • Press Releases
    • RealEstate
    • RealEstate
    • Finance
    • Insurance
    • Banks
      • GeoBanks
    • Markets
    • Press Releases
    • Personal Finance
  • World
    • America
    • Europe
    • Georgia
      • Media
    • Ukraine
    • Europe
    • Georgia
      • Media
    • Ukraine
    • Americas
    • UK local news
  • Travel
    • Hotels in Georgia
    • Tours in Georgia
  • Videos
    • Promos
    • Soundslides
    • TheClinics
    • TheHoteliers
    • TheUniversities
    • TheHoteliers
    • TheClinics
    • TheUniversities
    • BestWorkplaces
    • Soundslides
    • Promos
    • Banking Forum
      • Promos
      • Soundslides
      • TheClinics
      • TheHoteliers
      • TheUniversities
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
      • Analysis
      • GORBI
      • OP-ED
      • VISA Editorial
    • Analysis
    • Gorbi
    • Book reviews
  • Tech
  • Interview
  • People
    • CityLife
    • Health & Beauty
      • Coronavirus
    • LifeStyle
    • Employment
      • MyCareer
    • Education
    • Media
    • Celebrities
  • Oil&Auto
    • Auto
    • Energy
  • EN
    • EN
    • GE
No Result
View All Result
FINCHANNEL
No Result
View All Result
Home INTERVIEW

Interview: Why Putin Might Prefer A Stalemate To Going Nuclear On Ukraine

by The FINANCIAL
October 22, 2022
in INTERVIEW
0
Russian Patriarch Kirill Says Dying In Ukraine ‘Washes Away All Sins’
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Graham Allison is a Harvard professor and former U.S. defense official with expertise in nuclear weapons, Russia, China, and security planning. His 1971 book on the Cuban Missile Crisis is considered a seminal work. In the 1990s, as an assistant secretary of defense, Allison, 82, worked to coordinate U.S. strategy toward the successor states of the Soviet Union after the end of the Cold War.

ADVERTISEMENT

In a wide-ranging interview with Vazha Tavberidze from RFE/RL’s Georgian Service, the veteran former diplomat discusses why Russia’s Vladimir Putin is likely to keep escalating in Ukraine, possibly even opting for nuclear weapons, breaking a decades-old “taboo,” and plunging the globe into further uncertainty.

RFE/RL: Earlier this month, Putin celebrated his 70th birthday and a day later the Crimea Bridge was hit October 8 by what Moscow says was a truck bomb. After that, Russia launched what is believed to be its biggest coordinated air and missile raids on Ukraine since the start of the invasion on February 24, indicating Putin is willing to escalate. What’s his next likely move?

RelatedPosts

“EU membership might attract European banks and other financial institutions to enter Georgia” – NBG Vice Governor Papuna Lezhava

“As a member of the ProCredit Group, we provide significant advantages to SME’s, by partnering with EU organizations” – Giorgi Kardenakhlishvili, Head of Medium Business Development, ProCredit Bank Georgia

‘Russia cannot be treated as a reasonable and reliable trade partner

We should increase our joint efforts to assist the growing tech sector here in Georgia

Graham Allison: If Putin is forced to choose between humiliating defeat, on the one hand, and escalating the level of destruction…there’s every reason to believe he chooses the latter. As you step up the level of destruction, the first step is bombing infrastructure. And I think that’s what he’s doing now, even though he doesn’t have as many smart bombs as he would like to, you know, so they are not as carefully targeted, but one up that ladder of destruction is just destroying people.

A humiliating defeat for Russia in Ukraine would not, I believe, be existential for Russia…but I think it will be existential for Putin.

The Western narrative, and especially [Ukrainian President Volodymyr] Zelenskiy’s, has asserted that Putin was killing a lot of civilians. Actually, he’s not been killing very many, if you think about it in historical terms. If he wanted to kill children, if he wanted to kill thousands of people, he can bomb Kyiv; there’s nothing preventing him from sending bombers to bomb Kyiv or striking Kyiv with hundreds of missiles. So, there’s plenty of population centers.

So, I think in the first instance, he’s going after infrastructure, because he wants to freeze Ukraine and make their lights go out and whatever. Yeah, but then right on up that becomes killing people. And then after that comes chemical weapons, and then after that comes nuclear strikes.

RFE/RL: You paint a very grim picture of where the conflict could be headed.

Allison: It’s a very ugly picture. And even though a humiliating defeat for Russia in Ukraine would not, I believe, be existential for Russia — Russia can survive without Ukraine — but I think it will be existential for Putin.

RFE/RL: Are we nearing that moment when Putin feels he’s cornered?

Allison: I think yes. As [U.S.] President [Joe] Biden said, in private remarks which were made public last week, that he thinks we’re stumbling along the path to that point.

RFE/RL: If there indeed is a targeted nuclear strike in Ukraine, for example, as a show of decisive force, what could that mean not only for Ukraine, but also Russia, the rest of the world?

Allison: It’s the question, obviously, that every thoughtful person in Washington, which are many, and certainly President Biden, and all of his national-security team have been asking. It’s a question that Europeans are asking, and they should be asking. So, what is the big picture? We’ve had seven decades without the use of nuclear weapons in war. That’s remarkable. That’s not natural. That’s an accomplishment. The nuclear taboo has emerged slowly, but it has emerged. And, fortunately, states have refrained from the use of nuclear weapons.

Putin certainly has the capability to conduct a nuclear strike. He would have reason, in his view, to conduct a nuclear strike if he thought there was some chance that it would allow him to come out as a victor rather than a loser. Putin doesn’t think of himself as a loser and will be desperate, I believe, as CIA director [William] Burns has said, to find some way out, if he’s backed into a corner.

So, I think if he should do this, we will be living, as Biden has said, in a new world. How the U.S. and its Western allies will respond is not certain. A lot would depend on what the use of the nuclear weapon, you know what would be the target. So, he could have a ‘demonstration bomb,’ just blow up something in the forest or in the Black Sea. He could hit a military target, he could hit a city.

So, if you listen to what he said last week, he said [former U.S. President Harry] Truman dropping the bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki were the precedent. That’s what he said. Well, in Hiroshima, the bomb that the Americans dropped on Hiroshima, killed 140,000 people. So, a nuclear strike on Kyiv with a tactical nuclear weapon, that could deliver the same blast — 15 kilotons as the Hiroshima bomb — could kill quite a lot of people in here. So, you think, ‘Oh, my God, what would the response be to that?’ I believe, Washington had been working through the whole menu of options.

RFE/RL: Do you believe one of those options, that Washington is weighing a nuclear response?

Allison: Washington would say everything is on the table. But a nuclear response seems to me to be highly unlikely, and I would say would be ill-considered. Since the question would be then how would Putin respond to that? So, you’re into an area in which you have bad options and worse options, no good options. And that’s why there’s such an intense effort now, to persuade Putin that this is a really bad idea, including for himself, for his country, for the world. He’s got to figure this out for himself, in terms of both what the U.S. and the West would do in response, and also advice I’m hoping he’s getting from some of the people he trusts more, like China.

RFE/RL: In an interview with Der Spiegel a few months ago, you said: “We will have to end a war with the demon,” and the examples that you offered were how [former U.S. President Franklin Delano] Roosevelt and [former U.K. Prime Minister Winston] Churchill sat down with [former Soviet dictator Josef] Stalin, who obviously killed millions of people, or [former U.S. President Richard] Nixon with [former Chinese communist leader] Mao [Zedung], who was also no slouch when it came to killing people. So, let me ask you: How would that kind of deal with the devil look when it comes to Putin?

Allison: I have an unorthodox view about this. If you listen to President Biden, if you read his comments, they’re clearly thinking about off-ramps — that’s the way that Washington thinks about this.

So, my optimistic scenario would be that in the next month or two, one gets to essentially a stalemate. Probably somewhere along the current line of control, probably with Ukraine controlling most of what’s west of the Dnieper and the other river there (Inhulets River), near Kherson, and Russia controlling most of the other side; that the fighting declines to a low level, kind of like what happened between 2016 to 2020 in the so-called independent republics of Donetsk and Luhansk.

Amid Putin’s Saber-Rattling, What Exactly Is A Tactical Nuclear Weapon?

And that at that stage, Putin thinks he has enough to declare that he’s been successful. He’s got his land bridge to Crimea; he’s taken in some additional territory. So, he says, he’s being successful. And we say we are successful, because we say Ukraine survived as a free and independent country, it’s not giving up any of its territory. It’s claiming that it’s going to recover those territories at some point, but not today. And Ukraine will focus on building a successful country, which will be extremely hard to do, but in which they have a moral claim, I think, on the West for major financial support for the undertaking.

And then my story, this is my good news story, would be [that]this continues for a year or two or five. I remember the story of East Germany and West Germany. West Germany never gave up its claim to East Germany. It just showed what a free society could do, relative to a Soviet-controlled autocracy. Or North Korea and South Korea; or more relevant for Ukraine: how about the Baltics?

Putin’s playbook in Ukraine looks to me to be taken directly from the communist playbook in the Baltics, at the end of World War Two, when they held sham elections, sham referenda, they annexed Latvia, Lithuania, and Estonia and called them republics of the Soviet Union. The West, the U.S. did not recognize the Soviet Union’s claim to those territories, neither did people living outside, and in time, they emerged as free states.

So that can take a long time. That’s unfortunate. But since the alternative would be something even worse, I would regard that is an optimistic scenario.

Vazha Tavberidze is a Vaclav Havel Journalism Fellow working with RFE/RL’s Georgian Service. As a journalist and political analyst, he has covered issues of international security, post-Soviet conflicts, and Georgia’s Euro-Atlantic aspirations. His writing has been published in various Georgian and international media outlets, including The Times, The Spectator, The Daily Beast, and IWPR.

ADVERTISEMENT
The FINANCIAL

The FINANCIAL

Since 2005

Related Posts

“EU membership might attract European banks and other financial institutions to enter Georgia” – NBG Vice Governor Papuna Lezhava
INTERVIEW

“EU membership might attract European banks and other financial institutions to enter Georgia” – NBG Vice Governor Papuna Lezhava

by The FINANCIAL
May 15, 2023
0

Q. National Bank of Georgia was planning to regulate crypto market in Georgia. What was done so far?  A. In...

Read more
“As a member of the ProCredit Group, we provide significant advantages to SME’s, by partnering with EU organizations” – Giorgi Kardenakhlishvili, Head of Medium Business Development, ProCredit Bank Georgia

“As a member of the ProCredit Group, we provide significant advantages to SME’s, by partnering with EU organizations” – Giorgi Kardenakhlishvili, Head of Medium Business Development, ProCredit Bank Georgia

May 15, 2023
‘Russia cannot be treated as a reasonable and reliable trade partner

‘Russia cannot be treated as a reasonable and reliable trade partner

February 13, 2023
We should increase our joint efforts to assist the growing tech sector here in Georgia

We should increase our joint efforts to assist the growing tech sector here in Georgia

February 13, 2023
Next Post

1979 Aston Martin Bulldog Gets Modern Restoration As It Seeks To Break 200mph Speed Barrier

Please login to join discussion
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Find Social Security Number by Name Free

Find Social Security Number by Name Free

November 23, 2022
Most Northwest Drivers Aren’t Worried about Car Prowls

The Illinois-based insurer remains the largest US private auto writer

May 8, 2023
Humana shares on the up as earnings show Medicare growth

Humana shares on the up as earnings show Medicare growth

May 8, 2023
How to Check KRA Pin Using ID Number

How to Check KRA Pin Using ID Number

June 25, 2018
EasyJet to fly to London from Stockholm Arlanda

The London Diplomatic List, Addresses, Contacts & Working Hours

January 23, 2023
How to optimize business costs with Intranet implementation?

Protected: 5 Key Advantages of Contact Center Solutions Every Business Must Know

May 30, 2023
New direction in the construction and development market of Georgia – “Prestige” series from “Maqro Construction”

New direction in the construction and development market of Georgia – “Prestige” series from “Maqro Construction”

May 26, 2023
Long-term international migration, provisional: year ending December 2022

Long-term international migration, provisional: year ending December 2022

May 26, 2023
putin_copy_copy.jpg

Blow for Putin as UK marks one year free from Russian gas

May 25, 2023
About a third of Americans would tell a high schooler seeking career advice to enter a STEM-related field

Recruitment firms are not effective if you want to make a big career change

May 25, 2023

Popular Last 24h

  • Find Social Security Number by Name Free

    Find Social Security Number by Name Free

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Recruitment firms are not effective if you want to make a big career change

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Humana shares on the up as earnings show Medicare growth

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Swedish banks’ commercial property problem loans lowest in Europe – EBA

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • New direction in the construction and development market of Georgia – “Prestige” series from “Maqro Construction”

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Global Finance: TBC Bank in the World’s Best Banks 2023

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • American Friends of Georgia (AFG) held Annual Charity Gala on April 1, 2023 at the Sheraton Grand Tbilisi Metechi Palace Hotel first time after Covid pandemic outbreak.

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

LATEST POSTS

How to optimize business costs with Intranet implementation?

Protected: 5 Key Advantages of Contact Center Solutions Every Business Must Know

May 30, 2023
New direction in the construction and development market of Georgia – “Prestige” series from “Maqro Construction”

New direction in the construction and development market of Georgia – “Prestige” series from “Maqro Construction”

May 26, 2023
Long-term international migration, provisional: year ending December 2022

Long-term international migration, provisional: year ending December 2022

May 26, 2023
putin_copy_copy.jpg

Blow for Putin as UK marks one year free from Russian gas

May 25, 2023
About a third of Americans would tell a high schooler seeking career advice to enter a STEM-related field

Recruitment firms are not effective if you want to make a big career change

May 25, 2023
Home values in U.S. decline for second month as competition eases

Understanding The True Cost of Buying a Home Warranty

May 25, 2023
Formal Credit Channels Remain a Double-Edged Sword for Consumers

Formal Credit Channels Remain a Double-Edged Sword for Consumers

May 25, 2023
Hassan Jameel

Protected: Abdul Latif Jameel Energy’s FRV Expands Operations in Europe

May 23, 2023
First wiring map of neurons in insect brain complete

Brain signatures for chronic pain identified in a small group of individuals

May 22, 2023
New York Allows Sale Of Alcoholic Beverages During Coronavirus Shutdown As Market Shrinks To $528 Billion

Scrapping retained EU red tape on wine to unlock £180 million

May 21, 2023

LATEST INTERVIEWS

“EU membership might attract European banks and other financial institutions to enter Georgia” – NBG Vice Governor Papuna Lezhava

“EU membership might attract European banks and other financial institutions to enter Georgia” – NBG Vice Governor Papuna Lezhava

by The FINANCIAL
May 15, 2023
0

“As a member of the ProCredit Group, we provide significant advantages to SME’s, by partnering with EU organizations” – Giorgi Kardenakhlishvili, Head of Medium Business Development, ProCredit Bank Georgia

“As a member of the ProCredit Group, we provide significant advantages to SME’s, by partnering with EU organizations” – Giorgi Kardenakhlishvili, Head of Medium Business Development, ProCredit Bank Georgia

by The FINANCIAL
May 15, 2023
0

‘Russia cannot be treated as a reasonable and reliable trade partner

‘Russia cannot be treated as a reasonable and reliable trade partner

by The FINANCIAL
February 13, 2023
0

We should increase our joint efforts to assist the growing tech sector here in Georgia

We should increase our joint efforts to assist the growing tech sector here in Georgia

by The FINANCIAL
February 13, 2023
0

‘Georgia has much to offer to UK investors

‘Georgia has much to offer to UK investors

by The FINANCIAL
February 13, 2023
0

‘The best way for the Georgian economy to prosper is to join the EU

‘The best way for the Georgian economy to prosper is to join the EU

by The FINANCIAL
February 13, 2023
0

‘The Kremlin wants Georgia to fail or abandon its European path

‘The Kremlin wants Georgia to fail or abandon its European path

by The FINANCIAL
February 13, 2023
0

Russian Patriarch Kirill Says Dying In Ukraine ‘Washes Away All Sins’

Interview: Why Putin Might Prefer A Stalemate To Going Nuclear On Ukraine

by The FINANCIAL
October 22, 2022
0

Newsletter

ADVERTISEMENT

GET IN TOUCH

E-mail your company news at:

news (at) financial.ge Letters to the Editor: editor (at) finchannel.com

Local Marketing contact:

(+99532) 2252 275 | 76 EXT: 1 (+995 558) 03 03 03 (mobile) marketing (at) finchannel.com

Requests from abroad:

(+99532) 2252 275 | 76 EXT: 7 (+995599) 96 52 52 Email: zviadi (@) finchannel.com Contact video editor: E-mail: video (at) financial.ge

Postal address: 17 Mtskheta str. Tbilisi, Georgia 0179 The FINANCIAL

RESOURCE

  • Work at the FINANCIAL
  • ePaper
  • Advertise in The FINANCIAL
  • Access ePaper
  • Guest posts
  • Contributed articles
  • AmericanStockNews
  • Coupon Codes
  • GLOSSY MAG
American Culture Center
ACC Partner

GUIDEBOOK

  • Meet our team
  • Invest in Georgia
  • Become contributor
  • Archive

FOLLOW US

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Youtube
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Business
    • BANKS
      • GeoBanks
    • Finance
    • Insurance
    • Markets
    • Pharmacy
    • Press Releases
    • RealEstate
    • RealEstate
    • Finance
    • Insurance
    • Banks
      • GeoBanks
    • Markets
    • Press Releases
    • Personal Finance
  • World
    • America
    • Europe
    • Georgia
      • Media
    • Ukraine
    • Europe
    • Georgia
      • Media
    • Ukraine
    • Americas
    • UK local news
  • Travel
    • Hotels in Georgia
    • Tours in Georgia
  • Videos
    • Promos
    • Soundslides
    • TheClinics
    • TheHoteliers
    • TheUniversities
    • TheHoteliers
    • TheClinics
    • TheUniversities
    • BestWorkplaces
    • Soundslides
    • Promos
    • Banking Forum
      • Promos
      • Soundslides
      • TheClinics
      • TheHoteliers
      • TheUniversities
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
      • Analysis
      • GORBI
      • OP-ED
      • VISA Editorial
    • Analysis
    • Gorbi
    • Book reviews
  • Tech
  • Interview
  • People
    • CityLife
    • Health & Beauty
      • Coronavirus
    • LifeStyle
    • Employment
      • MyCareer
    • Education
    • Media
    • Celebrities
  • Oil&Auto
    • Auto
    • Energy
  • EN
    • EN
    • GE

© 2023 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.